Average Car Accident Settlement Amount in New York

Determining the average car accident settlement amount in New York would be very difficult: everyone’s settlement is based on their own unique, specific needs, and some settlements are kept confidential. Your own settlement will reflect all of your accident-related losses, so it is not necessary to determine an average to get the money you are entitled to.

The New York City car accident lawyers at Oresky & Associates, PLLC, will determine what a just car accident settlement looks like in your case and do everything possible — from negotiating with insurance companies to representing you at trial — to win that amount for you.

What Can I Get Compensation for After a Car Accident in NY?

Motor vehicle accidents occur frequently in New York. According to data from the New York City Police Department (NYPD), during a single week in January 2025, the city saw 1,229 collisions. These resulted in 704 injuries and 3 deaths.

Traffic crashes like these often inflict physical, emotional, and financial damage. Our car crash lawyers pursue car accident settlement payouts that include compensation for our clients’ non-economic and economic damages. You could recover money for:

• Past and future pain and suffering
• Reduced quality of life
• Disability
• Loss of consortium
• Medical expenses
• Property damage
• Lost wages and job benefits (e.g., union benefits)
• Loss of earnings

Our New York law firm will help you secure these and/or similar damages if you were involved in any kind of traffic crash, including a car accident, motorcycle accident, bicycle accident, or pedestrian accident.

Where Do Traffic Accidents Happen Most in NY?

A collision can happen anywhere that a driver engages in negligent behavior, such as distracted driving, improper lane changes, and speeding. However, it is true that some locations are more dangerous than others.

For example, in the Bronx, the intersections at Bruckner Boulevard/Longwood Avenue and the Major Deegan Expressway/W. 230th Street both saw multiple accidents in November 2024, according to NYPD data. In Queens that same month, the intersections at Belt Parkway/Lefferts Boulevard and the Cross Island Parkway/Long Island Expressway were similarly dangerous.

No matter where your collision happened, if you can prove that the other party was negligent, you can pursue a settlement for your car accident.

Call Now for a Free Consultation

Contact Oresky & Associates, PLLC, at (718) 993-9999 for a free, confidential consultation today. Our attorneys are ready to start protecting your rights.

Free Consultation

What Does My Car Accident Payout Amount Depend On?

All car accident settlements depend on what you have lost because of the liable party’s negligence. We will pursue a settlement or verdict based on your:

Accident Injury Type and Severity

Car accidents cause many different kinds of injuries, such as:

• Back injuries, including spinal cord injuries
• Neck injuries
• Traumatic brain injuries
• Cuts and lacerations
• Bone fractures
• Organ damage

Many of these injuries are treatable, while others result in permanent disabilities. Generally, the more serious your injuries are, the more money you could recover. Our New York law firm will take into account both your physical and emotional suffering and what impact your pain has had on your daily life as we calculate your settlement demand.

Financial Losses and Expenses

You are entitled to damages for all of the money you lost, either through additional expenses like medical bills or reduced income. The greater your financial losses are, the larger the settlement you can pursue from the at-fault party.

Car Accident Liability

If you are partly liable for the accident, you can still recover compensation. However, according to CPLR 1411, the amount you can recover depends on your share of liability.

Number of Liable Parties

Many car accidents involve only one at-fault party (e.g., the other driver). In cases where multiple parties contribute to a crash, you could qualify for a payout from more than one driver/insurance company. Our car accident lawyers will identify and seek compensation from everyone whose negligence played a role in your collision.

How to Maximize Your Car Accident Payout Amount in New York

Steps you can take to protect your rights include the following:

• Collect evidence: If you can safely do so, take photos and video before leaving the accident scene. You should also get the other driver’s license and insurance information. You are entitled to this information under VAT 600.
• See a doctor: Prioritize your health by getting prompt treatment. The medical record you create by doing so will help prove the severity of your injuries and your case’s worth.
• Be careful about what you say: The liable party’s insurance company will try to undermine your case. Let our firm speak to them on your behalf and help you formulate how you reply when they ask questions.

The single most important thing you can do to maximize your settlement for a car accident is consult with our personal injury lawyers. We are very familiar with state and local laws that may affect your case, as well as the tactics that insurance companies use to undervalue injury claims.

Online car accident settlement calculators are available, but they are not as accurate as our legal team, which will closely investigate your situation and arrive at an amount that reflects your needs. Rather than entrusting your future to an automated tool, allow Oresky & Associates, PLLC, to evaluate your case and fight for just compensation.

Getting the Car Accident Settlement You Are Entitled To

Since 1992, Oresky & Associates, PLLC, has represented car accident victims, regardless of their legal status. We have recovered over $500 million in settlements and verdicts not by focusing on the average car accident settlement in New York but by providing customized, attentive representation to each of our clients.

Call our New York personal injury law firm at (718) 993-9999 for a free case review today and pay no attorney’s fees until we win. If you cannot travel, we will consult with you at your home, in the hospital, or via video call.